Faux News


On the Internet, Pagal Patrakar is a popular Indian journalist. The Facebook page for his news web site boasts a fan base of more than 1,06,700 readers and a Twitter following of more than 40,000 people, including politicians Shashi Tharoor and Omar Abdullah. The celebrated writer’s stories include the exclusive story of the man who sued deodorant makers Axe because he was unable to attract even a single girl and also a special feature on Indian cricketers who took ‘performance-reducing drugs on the West Indies tour’.
But unlike most journalists who swear by the truth, this one clearly announces that he has ‘no reliable sources’.
Pagal Patrakar writes for the web site Faking News and specialises in the genre of news satire.

“I started it to mock sensational and irresponsible journalism,” says Pagal Patrakar’s real world avatar, Rahul Roushan.
The Delhi-based IIM-A graduate satirizes a situation using the age-old tools of irony, sarcasm and hyperbole to “highlight any absurdity or hilarity that otherwise might not be visible or apparent”.

And just like FakingNews, the interweb has spawned a host of similar India-based web sites that spoof local current affairs, mock desi politics and take digs at the Indian media.
They have dedicated sections that serve up stories from every beat – be it business, sports, international news or Bollywood gossip.

Sites such as The Unreal Times, The Scoop Times, Sunkey, News That Matters Not, and Mindry are run by news junkies—some of whom are media students and former journalists themselves—and who spend their time looking for the most talked-about news stories, only so that they can create spoofs out of them.

Take the trio behind Sunkey (which is eccentric in Hindi), for instance. They scour news websites, watch screaming news anchors, and track trending topics on Twitter to make sure they have enough to spoof.
“The topics we select have to be newsy,” says Harsh Singh who created the site in March this year along with Vineet Singh and Mahendra Yadav, his classmates from management school. The three collaborate online via Facebook private messages to discuss story ideas.

“When we can’t find any hot topic or trend, we write on general stuff like cricket and Bollywood,” says Shah who refrains from subjects that “may hurt a section of the audience and/or communities”.

But the most enjoyable posts are the ones that have a mix of both reality and make-believe such as an image created by FakingNews of Uttar Pradesh chief minister Mayawati’s Facebook wall that has Rahul Gandhi and Amar Singh teasing her.

Roushan says posts that are popular often get picked up by the mainstream media. For example, Pagal Patrakar’s ‘Axe’ story was inadvertently reproduced in several newspapers, and even the foreign press. This, even after the site clearly has a disclaimer that reads: ‘Content of this web site, unless categorized as ‘Editorial’, is a work of fiction’.

And while most of these satirists will not shy away from parodying almost anybody; whether politician or Bollywood star, their main targets are generally mainstream media.
“Most of the news you see on TV today is vague and untrue,” says the editor of The Scoop Times and who only wants to be known by his online handle of NewsMan BaBa. “I have most fun parodying the indiscriminate sensationalism we see on television news channels nowadays.”

Similarly, Roushan of Faking News first started with a news satire blog in 2008 as a reaction to the falling standards of television journalism. “I also wanted to explore The Onion-style news in India,” says Roushan who currently is the only full-time writer on the blog and accepts articles from a team of six regular contributors. He is looking forward to the next few years as he intends to set up a FakingNews office soon.

International appeal
Indian news satire web sites are in their infancy and their stories and style still leave a lot to be desired. Most of these, however, take inspiration from international satire properties such as The Onion (www.theonion.com) that was launched in 1996 and today boasts over 7.5 million unique visitors every month.

Listed below are a few other international satire sites worth checking out:
http://www.private-eye.co.uk
http://www.slashnot.com
http://www.sportsPickle.com
http://www.Realcelebritynews.com

This article was originally written for and published in The Times of India

4 comments

  1. Sure…
    In fact, I would suggest you make that clear on your website header. As someone who spends a fair amount of time on the Internet, I can tell you one thing… visuals and video are two elements of a website that get instant eyeballs, as compared to text.
    Regards.

    Like

  2. Thanks for your reply.
    I understand what you pointed out.
    As far as our efforts are concerned, we have certain sections for different purposes. The post that you talk of is a visual feature, and not an article. Moreover, we have as many serious posts as humorous. The motto does not cover everything, but it lies behind most articles we publish. I hope you go through some textual posts too.

    Like

  3. Dear Tanay,
    Thanks for your feedback.
    I don’t think anyone will interpret it as “senseless humour”. The fact that you are taking the effort to look up the news and then satirize it is being appreciated.
    I did get a chance to see your post about a chat conversation between MMS and Sonia where he asks her whether he can come over for a sleepover.
    Really don’t know how that can “inspire change through humour”.
    Regards.
    -M

    Like

  4. Ma’am, I’m the editor of News That Matters Not (NTMN), one of the websites mentioned in the article. I write this due to a serious disappointment.

    The description about sites such as ours,

    “…and who spend their time looking for the most talked-about news stories, only so that they can create spoofs out of them”

    was extremely disappointing coming from a leading media organisation. It questions the purpose of our work, and presents it in bad light to those unfamiliar with satire writing. It shows a misunderstanding of the difference between purposeful satire and senseless humour. I felt it is offensive, if not to the new websites who are yet to move from humour to satire, then for those writers who wish to write satire for a purpose. Our motto has been to “inspire change through humour”, and to make the reader “think along as they get amused”.

    I expect you’ll understand that we don’t intend to just creates spoofs out of nothing, only to make readers laugh. Spoofing news is only a medium that we use, but our focus is somewhere else. I wrote this letter to let you know my disappointment in the way satire writing was conveyed to the reader.

    It would be great to have your opinion about this.
    I have also contacted you via email.

    Like

Leave a reply to Tanay Sukumar Cancel reply